Skip to main content

Preservation Law (HIPR 6200): Court Opinions

Information and resources for the Master of Historic Preservation students

Finding Opinions

Generally the court opinion databases are not a good place to start your research. There are just too many opinions.

Use them if:

  • Looking for a known opinion but you don't have the citation
    • Even then it helps to know the specific state or court and the date
  • Looking for unique terminology
    • Names of people, places, corporations
    • Diseases and drugs
    • Quoted material

Use the resources listed in the Researching a Legal Issue box (under Westlaw Campus Research tab) to focus your search or use statutes and cases already identified.

Orin S. Kerr, How to Read a Legal Opinion: A Guide for New Law Students, 11 Green Bag 51 (2007)

 Elements of court opinions:

  • Case law - The body of reported court opinions and recognition that courts "make law" with their opinions; generally statutes are changed or enacted to officially codify the "case law".
  • Decision - A determination arrived at after consideration of the facts and the law; commonly used interchangeably with Judgment. Basically, what is the outcome which can be as simple as 
    • Conviction overturned
    • Lower court affirmed
    • Motion for costs granted
  • Dicta/Dictum - statements, remarks, or observations of a judge expressed in the opinion
  • Holding - the legal principle which can be drawn from the opinion
  • Opinion - The court's statement of its decision in a particular cause of action, setting out the law applied to the case and detailing the reasons for the decision. This is the why of a decision.
  • Judgment -  final and official determination of the resolution of a dispute and rights of the parties; commonly used interchangeably with Decision
  • Federal and State Cases Search
    • Click the jurisdiction box (between the search bar and magnifying glass icon)
    • Uncheck All Federal
    • Check the particular court or courts you need
    • Click Save

Special Collections Librarian

Sharon Bradley's picture
Sharon Bradley
University of Georgia
School of Law
225 Herty Drive
Athens, GA 30602
University of Georgia Law LibraryUniversity of Georgia  |  Non-Discrimination Policy  |  Privacy Policy  | Contact Site Administrator 
225 Herty Drive Athens, GA 30602-6012 | (706) 542-5077 | University of Georgia School of Law.  All rights reserved.