Skip to main content

Preservation Law (HIPR 6200): Court Opinions

Information and resources for the Master of Historic Preservation students

Finding Opinions

Generally the court opinion databases are not a good place to start your research. There are just too many opinions.

Use them if:

  • Looking for a known opinion but you don't have the citation
    • Even then it helps to know the specific state or court and the date
  • Looking for unique terminology
    • Names of people, places, corporations
    • Diseases and drugs
    • Quoted material

Use the resources listed in the Researching a Legal Issue box (under LexisNexis Academic) to focus your search or use statutes and cases already identified.

Orin S. Kerr, How to Read a Legal Opinion: A Guide for New Law Students, 11 Green Bag 51 (2007)

 Elements of court opinions:

  • Case law - The body of reported court opinions and recognition that courts "make law" with their opinions; generally statutes are changed or enacted to officially codify the "case law".
  • Decision - A determination arrived at after consideration of the facts and the law; commonly used interchageably with Judgment. Basically, what is the outcome which can be as simple as 
    • Conviction overturned
    • Lower court affirmed
    • Motion for costs granted
  • Dicta/Dictum - statements, remarks, or observations of a judge expressed in the opinion
  • Holding - the legal principle which can be drawn from the opinion
  • Opinion - The court's statement of it's decision in a particular cause of action, setting out the law applied to the cause and detailing the reasons for the decision. This is the why of a decision.
  • Judgment -  final and official determination of the resolution of a dispute and rights of the parties; commonly used interchageably with Decision
  • Federal and State Cases Search
    • Select "Advanced Options"
    • Uncheck "All Federal & State Courts" 
    • Check the particular court or courts you need
    • Click "Apply"
    • Note that under the red search box "Source" indicates the specific court you are searching.

Special Collections Librarian

Sharon Bradley's picture
Sharon Bradley
University of Georgia
School of Law
225 Herty Drive
Athens, GA 30602
University of Georgia Law LibraryUniversity of Georgia  |  Non-Discrimination Policy  |  Privacy Policy  | Contact Site Administrator 
225 Herty Drive Athens, GA 30602-6012 | (706) 542-5077 | Copyright 2018, University of Georgia School of Law.  All rights reserved.